The largest insurance firms in the United States provide a range of costs, customer experiences, and benefits. Regardless of size, they differ in price, service quality, and other features. Here is a closer look at the top ten vehicle insurance companies in the United States, ranked by premiums issued, market share, and ratings.
Top ten car insurance companies in the United States based on written premiums
Here are the top ten auto insurance firms in the United States based on premiums written in 2023.
State Farm: $40.4 billion.
Features include an extensive network of local agents, a wide range of discounts, and a smartphone app for convenient management.
Cons: More than average complaints about claim processing.
Geico: $33.9 billion.
Features include competitive prices, a robust web presence, and a variety of discount opportunities.
Cons: Limited local agent available.
Progressive: $33.2 billion.
Allstate: $25.9 billion.
Features include comprehensive coverage options, local agents, and the Drivewise program, which offers responsible driving savings.
Cons: Some drivers pay higher premiums.
USAA: $15.8 billion.
Features include excellent customer service, affordable rates for military members and their families, and a diverse choice of financial products.
Cons: Available only to military personnel and their families.
Farmers make $12.2 billion.
Features include customizable policies, a range of discounts, and access to local agents.
Cons: Above-average rates.
Liberty Mutual holds $11.8 billion.
Features include a wide selection of coverage options, accident forgiveness, and better vehicle replacement.
Cons: Mixed feedback on customer service.
Nationwide: $5.8 billion.
Features include the Vanishing Deductible Program, On Your Side Review, and a variety of discounts.
Cons: Customers receive average service ratings.
American Family: $5.2 billion.
Features: Ideal for bundling with other insurance products, excellent customer service, and a variety of discounts.
Cons: Availability is limited to specific states.
Travelers spend $4.9 billion.
Features include a broad choice of coverage options, the IntelliDrive program for responsible driving discounts, and excellent financial stability.
Cons: Some drivers pay higher premiums.
The top ten car insurance companies in the United States based on market share
The top ten auto insurance firms in the United States, ranked by market share, are:
State Farm: 15.93 percent.
Pros include the largest market share, a large network of agents, and the ability to bundle insurance.
Cons: More than average complaints concerning claims.
Geico: 14.31%.
Pros: Competitive pricing, robust online tools, and a variety of discounts.
Cons: Limited agent network.
Progressive: 13.71 percent.
Pros: Name Your Price tool, Snapshot program, and a range of coverage alternatives.
Cons: Mixed customer service experiences.
Allstate: 10.37%.
Pros: Full coverage, local agents, and safe driving incentives.
Cons: Some drivers pay higher premiums.
USAA: 6.01%
Pros: Great client service, competitive prices for military families, and financial goods.
Cons: Open only to military personnel and their families.
Liberty Mutual has a 4.88% rating and offers several coverage options, accident forgiveness, and better car replacement.
The top insurance firms in the United States offer a variety of coverage options and features. Larger carriers are more likely to provide tailored policies and specialized coverage, such as rideshare insurance. State Farm, Geico, Progressive, and Allstate are the top four insurers by market share and premiums issued. Each organization has strengths and disadvantages, so compare them depending on your individual requirements.